Guide to Debating Games at HumanodeCon 24

Humanode Core -

Two teams compete to persuade viewers and participants on a given topic. The debate's outcome is determined by votes after each round and a final calculation of the average voting results.

Game Structure

Teams: Two teams (Team A and Team B), each with 3-5 members.

Rounds: Three rounds, each consisting of:

  1. Thesis Statement
  2. Rebuttal
  3. Rebuttal of the Rebuttal

After Round 3: Conclusive Speeches by both teams.

Voting: Conducted after each round and following the conclusive speeches.

Round Breakdown

  1. Thesis Statement
  • Each team presents their main argument.
  • Focus: Clearly define your stance with logical points and evidence.
  1. Rebuttal
  • Each team challenges the other's thesis.
  • Focus: Highlight weaknesses, inconsistencies, or lack of evidence in the opposing argument.
  1. Rebuttal of the Rebuttal
  • Each team defends their thesis and counters the rebuttal.
  • Focus: Strengthen your position while addressing the opponent's challenges.
  1. Conclusive Speeches (After Round 3)
  • Each team gives a final, concise speech to summarize their stance and emphasize key points.
  • Time Limit: 3-5 minutes per team.
  • Focus: Leave a lasting impression and solidify your argument in the minds of voters.

Voting Rules

  1. After each round, participants and viewers vote on which team's argument is more convincing.
  2. Final voting is conducted after the conclusive speeches.
  3. Votes are tallied for each round.
  4. The average of all round votes determines which opinion prevails.

Judging Criteria for Voting

  • Clarity: How well the arguments are explained.
  • Relevance: Alignment with the debate topic.
  • Persuasiveness: Convincing nature of the arguments.
  • Resilience: Ability to defend against counterarguments.
  • Delivery: Confidence, tone, and engagement.

Tips for Success

  1. Strategic Arguments: Build momentum across rounds by addressing feedback from voting results.
  2. Adaptation: Learn from earlier voting results to refine arguments in subsequent rounds.
  3. Impactful Conclusion: Use the conclusive speech to tie all points together and emphasize the strength of your position.
  4. Engage the Audience: Make arguments relatable and impactful to sway voters.

This format ensures dynamic interaction between teams and participants while emphasizing the importance of persuasion across all rounds!